Posts Tagged ‘ 9/11

The plume

I had bronchitis for the second time this year last week, and during it I happened to be listening to Science Friday when they had Laurie Garrett on. They were talking about different things: her book, her work consulting for films, and several different aspects of the environmental impacts of 9/11.

She talked about something that has gone under the radar for some time: that the plume of smoke from the World Trade Center towers’ collapse completely enveloped parts of Brooklyn and other western parts of NYC that day. It’s not like it’s never been discussed, but it’s really not been part of public discussion.

So I’m listening to her talk about the chemical effects of burning jet fuel + asbestos + the insides of thousands of computers and other electronic devices, and all I can think about is how normal it’s become for me to cart around an inhaler, how I can expect any cold to go straight to my lungs, and it sends me back to how hard it was to breathe that day and I realized I never actually needed or owned an inhaler before then.

Most years, you know, I write something about 9/11 – something about the experience or a perspective of how the general tragedy of it is used/abused in our political system, but this year I think we should pay attention to all those emergency responders who still can’t get support for health care for diseases they acquired working at ground zero, to the decisions at the EPA about what was deemed safe and what was not and why, and to the people who were not in lower Manhattan, but saw their worlds shrouded in dust as well.

Before and after

Oh, GTFO already

Just about every year around this time, I write something about 9/11. It’s kind of cathartic for me to memorialize the experience, to reflect on how we weathered that day – not knowing where our friends were, struggling to get through on the phones, breathing in the ash – but this year I am particularly crabby.

The radical right wing that now constitutes the bulk of the Republican party (bye bye, fiscal conservatives, please start your own party and stop wandering into the Democratic tent) just loves to talk about how terrible cities are. They particularly like insulting New York.

So this year, I would like to tell them to just GTFO. Stop pitching fits about the fact that we’re diverse places and that you don’t like how we operate and then lament 9/11. If you hate cities, then you shouldn’t give a rat’s ass that we were targeted. No one crashed into or blew up your buildings. No one killed your people. You were completely and utterly ignored.

It is simply not right for you to claim our pain and then dismiss our people. We are only part of your “America” while you’re using the horrific day to justify your behavior. You don’t give a damn about what happened, you only give a damn about being able to hate others free of guilt and justifying your irrational and xenophobic fears.

So GTFO. I’m sick of trying to be civil when your version of the day was a TV show and yet you act like the horrible event we experienced in New York City belongs to you. You were never targeted, you didn’t have to live with the reality of the day – nor did you have to live with the after effects of constant bomb scares and military suddenly present on your daily commute.

Take your 9/12 crap and shove it. Take your famewhore pastor and shove him. Get a damned clue.

I am a real American

On Monday’s Daily Show, the writers took aim at this idea of “Real America.”

While I could break this down intellectually – what that means, why it’s used – the whole thing is so visceral to me that I don’t really feel like doing that today.

When that guy from Wasilla talked about how New Yorkers will pass by a guy lying in the street and that 9/11 brought out the best in the country (ignoring Jason Jones’s quick note that 9/11 happened in New York), I wanted to scream.

I have been an urban-dweller for my entire adult life – St. Paul, Minneapolis, Manhattan, Brooklyn – and I am a liberal and not ashamed of it. I am also a real American. Real America isn’t confined to white people in small towns. There are millions of us – millions – living in cities in this country, millions of Americans who are not white, millions of Americans who are not conservative – socially or otherwise – millions of Americans who are immigrants or whose parents are immigrants or whose grandparents are immigrants.

This country is ours, too. We are Real Americans too.

When I stood on the roof of my apartment building and watched the World Trade Center disintegrate and obliterate the skyline; when my neighborhood was choked with ash; when I and my friends and neighbors waited for some kind of contact to know that the people we cared about were safe; when my friends and fellow New Yorkers who worked in the city walked miles in confusion and fear just trying to make it home – no one I know would have said that we as Americans, and we as the world, didn’t feel that pain together.

And then Jerry Falwell came out and blamed gay people and feminists and then for the next eight years the Republicans made 9/11 an us versus them game. “Us” being people who were conservative and “Them” being people like me – with a different ideological view of how we fix society, as well as someone who was there.

You know what, FOX news? You know what, Michele Bachmann? You know what, Sarah Palin? You don’t get to decide who Real America is. There is no “Real America.”

Just because I happen to disagree with you on what this country needs doesn’t mean you get to throw me out.

I think you’re wrong on defense, wrong on morality, wrong on taxes, and wrong on social programs. I think the policies you promote are perpetuating inequality and making it harder for us to work together as a country and respect each American’s unique experience and life. I think that you call people names so you don’t have to debate issues because your ideas don’t stand up to actual debate. I think you use catch phrases so you don’t have to explain your ideas.

But I’m not going to tell you you’re not American. Because here in these big cities, we grow good people, people with values, civic-minded people who want to create better schools and better lives for ourselves and others, but America isn’t a series of stars on a map.

Like it or not, we’re in this together, and it’s time to start acting like adults.